September 2022 | Issue 3
Faculty Survey and Diversity Engagement Survey Report
- 39 Respondents / 91 Immunology Faculty ~ 43% response rate
- Quantitative scores paint rosier picture than Qualitative comments
- “I don't think online training modules will help. Honestly, I think many of our more senior faculty across the university (not necessarily in immunology) think DEI is a joke and frankly they need to go and we need a new generation with capacity for neural plasticity.”
- “I also attend DEI meetings offered by the University… Notably, no male faculty from immunology ever participate in these things.”
“I think that my lab is one of the more diverse ones in the Immunology program, but this may be a happy accident rather than the result of an intense focus on diversity in my hiring. I mainly prioritize finding lab members who are interested in the subject, open-minded, kind and thoughtful toward others, and who enjoy working hard.”
Diversity Engagement Survey Report for the Immunology Program
- A total of 31-40 students, postdocs, staff, and faculty
- • 27 were graduate students, approximately half were non-male and less than half were non-white.
- 8 categories of questions were asked with multiple these included:
- • Access to Opportunity, Appreciation of Individual Attributes, Common Purpose, Cultural Competence, Equitable Reward and Recognition, Respect, Sense of Belonging, and Trust.
- For this summary we chose to highlight 4 question from 3 of the 8 categories,
- • Cultural Competence, Sense of Belonging and Trust within the Immunology program.
We evaluated the aggregated respondent's response to these question based on demographics such as role, whether they were a graduate student or all other merged groups
- There is a disconnect between faculty perceived understanding of DEI issues and graduate student overall experiences.
- Postdocs feel largely left out of the immunology program [conclusions from the Diversity Engagement Survey].
CD3 Committee Advice
- Although CD3 thnks male and senior faculty for participating in the committee, we need more active participation!
- Faculty should attend happy hours with post doc and students
- Faculty should work to incorporate DEIB efforts in their day-to-day activities.
- Faculty should work to create environments of belonging.
Moving Forward: Faculty suggested efforts to improve DEI
- “The NexGen symposium has been fantastic.”
- “More efforts should be taken to recruit DEIB trainees and faculty. It needs to be a priority of the faculty who are participating in recruitment.”
- “Sign up for SSRP [ ADVANCE, REACH or PROPEL] students.”
- “Work on diseases of the needy and not diseases of the rich.”
- “I think we have good programs for recruiting diverse trainees, but we need to do a better job of creating a nurturing environment, retaining them, and increasing diversity of faculty.”
- “Don't let people with obvious prejudices continue to serve on admissions committees.”
Other suggestions from the CDIII committee for faculty participation
- Immunology Preview weekend (Sept 27th, 2022)
- Annual Immunology Scientific conference discussion (Jan 27th - 29th, 2023)
- PROSPER program (First cohort: Fall 2022)
- Join CDIII (New faculty recruitment: Fall 2022)
- Attend Immunology social events such as happy hours (monthly and quarterly meetings)
- Participate in DEIB trainings (more information to come in a follow up email)
It's been hard to cultivate a sense of community amidst a pandemic, but I feel that there could be some more interplay between the faculty and students that creates space for this. It would be good to have more candid conversations about shared ideals, missions and ways to support each other along the journey.
In the pursuit of transparency links to the aggregate data from both surveys are provided below. Please log in with your Stanford SUNet ID on Google.com to view.
If you have suggestions to improve our newsletter, please contact us at email@example.com
- Meet the 2022 CDIII Committee Members
- New Initiative: Prosper Program
- SIRPA (Stanford Immunology Review Program for Applicants)
- 2021 Faculty Survey Highlights
- Community, Diversity and Inclusion in Immunology (CDIII) Committee Mission
- Meet the 2021 CDIII Committee Members
- Starting October 2020, We've Been Meeting Monthly
- Programs Established During 2021
- Still a Long Way to Go!