Launching the Application
To log into the Cohort Identification Tool, browse to https://stride-service.stanford.edu/stride/web/
If after authenticating via WebAuth you are presented with an error message, please contact us by completing the form at https://redcap.stanford.edu/plugins/gethelp/ with a detailed description of the error message you are seeing.
The Toolbar, located at the top of the window, contains four buttons: Searches, Count, Analyse and Review.
Clicking on Searches shows you your recent and saved searches. If you wish to conduct a follow-on Chart Review we request that you save your search by name.
Clicking on Count will count the number of distinct patients specified by your search criteria (more on that later). It is greyed out until you have constructed a valid search query.
Clicking on Analyse shows some simple graphs of frequency of occurrence of selected demographic and clinical indicators. Click on the 'x' in the upper-right corner of the visualization to return to your search criteria.
Review merely shows you some help text on how to request permission for chart review.
Underneath the toolbar you are presented with a menu of constraint types used to specify which patients you are interested in.
The Search Elements allow you to construct a patient cohort by applying a series of filter criteria. The current search elements are broken into three categories: Demographics, Clinical Events, and Temporal Constraints. To add a criteria to the search simply click on it. You may also add the criteria by clicking and dragging it from the left side to where you want to place it. Some criteria can be added multiple times. Multiple search criteria are evaluated with the logical AND operator - meaning only those patients that meet all criteria will be included in the total patient count.
This data category contains Current Age, Gender, Race and Ethnicity. These criteria are NOT required to create a patient cohort search and should ONLY be used if you require that the cohort search be constrained by these criteria. Please note that 'Current Age' calculates the patient age at the time of the search whereas 'Age at event' in a Clinical Events filter calculates patient age at the time of the relevant clinical event.
This data category permits you to search based on a variety of clinically relevant information, including: diagnosis, procedure, lab test performed, numeric lab results, drug ingredients or brand, drug class, contents of clinical documents, and vital status. In addition, each event can be further filtered by specifying the patients' age at the time of the event or the date range in which the event occurred. You can search for the intersection of two events (logical AND) by adding a filter more than one time to your search. You can search on the union of two events (logical OR) by clicking on the 'plus' sign on the right side of an active clinical event filter. Please see the search examples below for more details.
Each clinical event in the Research Data Warehouse (RDW) has a date associated with its entry. Using the Temporal Constraint filter, you can refine your search based on the relative order or gap in time between a pair of events. For example, you can now easily find patients who took two different drugs within one month of each other over the entire timespan of the RDW.
Anatomy of a Search Constraint
To build your cohort, you select filters from the Search Elements area and drag them to the active search box on the right. Alternatively, you can double-click on a search filter and it will be added to your active query. Once a filter is added, there are a number of options to configure and customize. The following is an illustration of one such filter (Figure 2):
The following attributes are present in most Filter Elements or can be extrapolated to additional filter types.
A Presence or Absence of the Clinical Event Each clinical filter allows you to select for both the presence or the absence of an event. In this case, by clicking on section A you can toggle between a 'Diagnosis of (include only patients with the specified diagnosis)' or 'No Diagnosis of (exclude any patients with the specified diagnosis)'.
B Description of Event Begin by entering in your filtering criteria - many filters use an auto-complete feature to help you complete your query by displaying a list of matching terms. For example, start entering 'sore throat' and the auto-complete will show you the correct ICD-9 billing code of '034 Streptococcal sore throat and scarlet fever'
C Age at Event The age at event filter is present on all clinical event filters and can be toggled between four states: any age, less than or equal, greater than or equal, and between two dates (inclusive). This filter allows you to specify a patient age or age range during which the specified clinical event must have occurred (or not occurred). The age can be further refined to years, weeks, or days. For example, setting Age at Event is less than or equal to 18 years with an ICD-9 description of 277.0 Cystic fibrosis would find only those patients who had an ICD-9 diagnosis of Cystic Fibrosis when they were aged 18 years or less. Age at Event is a useful way to distinguish pediatric and adult patient cohorts.
D Event Date This condition allows you to specify a date or date range that will be used to decide which clinical events (diagnoses, procedures, documents and laboratory test results) are considered when applying the filter. Each diagnosis, procedure, document and laboratory test result received by the system has a date stamp attached, identifying when that data was created – i.e. the date of that "data event". For example, the query (ICD-9 Diagnosis is 277.0 Cystic fibrosis) AND (Encounter Date is on or after 01/01/2000) would include only those patients with a diagnosis of Cystic Fibrosis on or after January 1 2000.
E Add/Remove Description It is possible to add additional search terms to your filter, for example to search for '034 Streptococcal sore throat and scarlet fever' OR '462 Acute pharyngitis' in a single Diagnosis filter. These terms will be evaluated with the logical 'OR' clause, so either term will match. If you want to further limit a search by saying a patient must have BOTH '034 Streptococcal sore throat and scarlet fever' AND '462 Acute pharyngitis', you would create two Diagnosis filters - one for each ICD-9 code.
F Information By holding your mouse icon over the information icon, you will see approximate statistics for the number of records in the database for this filter.
G Remove Filter You can remove a filter from your search by clicking on the close 'x' icon in the upper right. This also applies to closing the summary statistics window.
Creating a Cohort
A patient cohort is created by first starting with all patient details in the Research Data Warehouse (RDW) and filtering for those with or without a certain property. The RDW provides you with approximate numbers for each filter you apply. When satisfied with the results of your query, you may save the query using the Action button in the toolbar.
Filtering By Diagnoses
The International Classification of Diseases (ICD) is widely used to code patient diagnoses for reimbursement, statistical, administrative and clinical needs. SUMC uses trained coding personnel to review patient charts and abstract ICD-9-CM codes following inpatient care. While neither ICD itself nor the human coding process is perfect, ICD codes are the most widely used system for capturing patient diagnoses in a standardized way. One advantage of ICD coding is that, at least theoretically, all patients that share a diagnosis are coded in the same way. ICD uses a shallow hierarchy of codes to represent a general diagnosis and more specific variants. For example Primary Pancreatic Cancer is represented in ICD as follows:
Malignant Neoplasm of Pancreas (157)
Malignant Neoplasm of Head of Pancreas (157.0)
Malignant Neoplasm of Body of Pancreas (157.1)
Malignant Neoplasm of Tail of Pancreas (157.2)
Malignant Neoplasm of Pancreatic Duct (157.3)
Malignant Neoplasm of Islets of Langerhans (157.4)
Malignant Neoplasm of Other Unspecified Sites of Pancreas (157.8)
Malignant Neoplasm of Pancreas, Part Unspecified (157.9)
Note: by selecting an integer parent code, all child codes are included (e.g., 157 will include 157.0, 157.1, ...)
The Cohort Discovery Tool also allows you to search for ICD 'E codes' and 'V-codes' as well. Though not strictly diagnoses, these codes logically fit into the general model of using disease states (including injuries, accidents, poisonings, drug adverse effects, medical and surgical misadventures) to define patient cohorts.
ICD-9-CM E-codes (external causes of injury and poisoning codes) are intended to provide data for injury research and evaluation of injury prevention strategies. E codes capture how the injury or poisoning happened (cause), the intent (unintentional or accidental; or intentional, such as suicide or assault), and the place where the event occurred.
ICD-9-CM provides V-codes to deal with encounters for circumstances other than a disease or injury. The Supplementary Classification of Factors Influencing Health Status and Contact with Health Services (V01.0 - V84.8) is provided to deal with occasions when circumstances other than a disease or injury (codes 001-999) are recorded as a diagnosis or problem.
A good source for ICD-9-CM information is:
An Example Search
Drag a new Diagnosis filter to your active search. Click in the text entry area of the criteria and type either an ICD code (e.g. 157.3) or an ICD term (e.g. Malignant Neoplasm of Pancreatic Duct) into the text field of the condition. As you type, the application will begin searching for matching ICD terms and display them in a popup menu:
ICD-9 auto-complete in diagnosis filter
A lot is going on here behind the scenes. The system will look at the text (or code) that you enter and attempt to interpret it, producing a list of suggested ICD codes that you can choose from. It supports the use of synonyms, so that, for example, entering breast cancer finds "breast neoplasms". Word order and case are ignored, so that "breast cancer" and "CANCER BREAST" are equivalent. The system will also attempt to display the suggested ICD codes with the most general code at the top of the list.
Selecting a general ICD code (e.g. Malignant neoplasm of the pancreas) instructs the system to include patients whose disease was coded with that ICD code or ANY of its more specific (children) codes. To be precise, selecting ICD code 157 Malignant Neoplasm of the Pancreas will instruct to tool to also search for 157.0, 157.1, 157.2, 157.3, 157.4 etc. Unless you are sure that you only want to include patients with a very specific diagnosis (e.g. 157.3 Malignant neoplasm of the pancreatic duct), it is often a good idea to select the more general (or parent) ICD code, as this will find all child codes for the disease.
Performing AND or OR Searches
The plus icon (E in figure 2) allows you to add another search term to a query. In the example above, if you wanted to search for patients with either of two specific ICD-9 codes, 157.0 OR 157.3, you would add a second search term to your query:
Union Queries - searching for A OR B
You can also use the OR search feature to include patients who have at least one of a number of diagnoses. For example if you are interested in patients with smoking-related cancers, one might create the following condition:
Multiple OR clauses to find smoking-related cancer patients.
On the other hand, if you wanted to find only patients with both of these diagnoses, you would add the diagnosis filter two times to the query window as illustrated below:
Intersection Queries - searching for both A AND B
Filtering By Procedures
Medical and surgical procedures performed on patients are coded using ICD and/or CPT (Current Procedural Terminology – see below) codes. In general inpatient procedures performed at SUMC are coded using ICD, while many outpatient procedures are coded using CPT. The Cohort Discovery Tool supports integrated searching of both inpatient and outpatient ICD and CPT coded procedures, using the Procedure condition. This operates in much the same way as the Diagnosis condition, supporting 'search as you type', intelligent lookup of ICD and CPT codes, ability to OR procedure codes as well as AND procedure codes. A major difference from diagnosis is that procedure code lookups may return a mixture of ICD and CPT procedure codes. The codes returned are displayed in three sections: CPT Hierarchical Codes ("CH" codes); Individual CPT Codes and ICD-9 Procedure Codes.
Procedural lookup illustrating mixture of ICD and CPT codes
When using the procedure condition in a cohort query you may wish to OR equivalent ICD and CPT codes together in a compound condition to ensure that you include patients who had a procedure performed as either an both inpatient or outpatients e.g.:
Procedural query using OR to include both ICD and CPT codes
CPT (Current Procedural Terminology) codes are categorized into three groups:
- Category I CPT codes describe a procedure or service identified with a five-digit CPT code (e.g. 29870) and descriptor nomenclature (Arthroscopy, knee, diagnostic, with or without synovial biopsy). The inclusion of a descriptor and its associated specific five-digit identifying code number in this category of CPT codes is generally based upon the procedure being consistent with contemporary medical practice and being performed by many physicians in clinical practice in multiple locations.
- Category II CPT codes are intended to facilitate data collection by coding certain services and/or test results that are agreed upon as contributing to positive health outcomes and quality patient care. This category of CPT codes is a set of optional tracking codes for performance measurement. These codes may be services that are typically included in an Evaluation and Management (E/M) service or other component part of a service and are not appropriate for Category I CPT codes.
- Category III CPT codes contains a temporary set of tracking codes for new and emerging technologies. Category III CPT codes are intended to facilitate data collection on and assessment of new services and procedures. These codes are intended to be used for data collection purposes to substantiate widespread usage or in the FDA approval process.
Searching Clinical Documents
The Cohort Discovery Tool allows searching inside clinical documents for words or phrases, as part of a patient cohort query. A large variety of clinical documents are supported:
Many different types of clinical documents can be searched
Multi-word text phrases can be searched using three methods:
- near each other - this generally means in the same sentence, independent of word order.
- in the same document - the words could be anywhere in the document
- exact phrase - this means the words must occur together and in order
In general you should choose the default 'near each other' option rather than the 'in same document' option. Case and punctuation are ignored when searching inside documents and word order is ignored for the 'near each other' and 'in same document' searches. If the 'near each other' operator is used, words do not need to be immediately adjacent to match.
Context and caveats when searching clinical documents
The utility of searching within clinical documents is somewhat limited by the absence of contextual information. Documents containing the phrase 'Myocardial Infarction' could use this term in many different contexts (e.g. 'a history of myocardial infarction', 'Father died of myocardial infarction', 'Rule-out myocardial infarction', 'Patient has no history of myocardial infarction' etc.). In addition this search would not include the document that states 'The patient says that he had a heart attack two months ago'. In addition, be aware negated terms, e.g. 'no evidence of myocardial infarction' would also be considered a match. We are working on strategies to address some of these issues.
Lab Orders and Results
The Cohort Discovery Tool supports using laboratory tests as conditions in cohort searches. Currently the application allows you to use laboratory tests by the type of test performed or by the quantitative results.
Filter by Test or Battery
You can including or exclude patients in a cohort based on the presence of a either a laboratory battery or an individual test measurement.
The following search selects patients who had a Hepatic Function Panel (includes Albumin, Alkaline Phosphatase, ALT (SGPT), AST (SGOT), Conjugated Bilirubin, and Unconjugated Bilirubin) or had a single AST test.
Searching for lab batteries or individual tests
The Stanford Clinical Laboratory (www.stanfordlab.com) maintains lists of lab codes and batteries that you may want to search. Many labs can be ordered with a variety of codes so it is common to use the 'OR' functionality to include all common lab variants.
Filter by Numeric Lab Result
You can including patients in a cohort only if they have a particular laboratory test numeric result value, or set of numeric result values.
To include a numeric test result in a patient cohort query, use the 'Numeric Lab Test Results' condition. Enter all or part of the name of the test that you are interested in and select a test from the list. Once the laboratory test is selected, you can choose from a menu of operators (see below) as to how you wish to specify the test result.
Filtering based on lab results
You can specify an actual value, a range of values or use 'high', 'low' or 'normal'. You can 'OR' or 'AND' multiple laboratory test results.
Filtering for lab results with high Troponin AND low calcium
Filtering with Temporal Constraints
The temporal constraint filter allows for filtering your results based on the proximity or order of events defined in two previous search filters.
The control on a Temporal Constraint filter.
Before adding this filter to your query, you should first create two or more clinical search filters that you wish refine with a temporal constraint. Next, drag or double click on the temporal constraint to add it to your query.
The two events you wish to compare should be set as Event A and Event B.
Since each event could actually have many results within it, the 'event date' filters allow you to select from three options: Any, Earliest, or Most Recent.
The 'order selector' sets the relative order of the two events and has three options: follows, precedes, or precedes or follows. The last option should be used when relative order does not not matter and you are only interested in proximity of events. Swapping events A and B is the same as switching the order selector.
The 'range for comparison' sets the time between the two events and has three options: less than, greater than, or between two values.
For example, if you wanted to determine a Cohort of patients who were prescribed Tylenol within 90 days after a liver transplant, you might formulate the query as:
Temporal filtering of events from two previous search filters
Each search filter may include many events (using the drug Tylenol, for example), it is important to take note of the (Any/Earliest/Most Recent) selector before each entry in the temporal constraint filter. Using 'Any' for both events could lead to confusing results. To search for events occurring on the same day, set the 'order selector' to precedes or follows and the 'range for comparison' to less than 1 day.
Protecting Patient Privacy
In addition to never revealing individual patient identifiers or data, the Cohort Discovery Tool uses a number of strategies to prevent "triangulation" of data that might identify an individual patient. As a consequence, total cohort sizes of less than ten patients are reported as "<10 Patients" and individual categories in criteria results and demographics graphs are reported in increments of 5, with a small random "fuzzy" rounding factor added to each search results to further prevent triangulation.